Introduction
The institution of slavery, specifically in the American South, was characterized by brutal violence and systemic oppression. Physical punishments and the stripping of autonomy were routine methods used to maintain the social order and racial hierarchy of the slave trade. For enslavers, the denial of education to enslaved people became a powerful tool of subjugation. However, enslaved peoples recognized the importance of literacy and knowledge in resistance, empowerment, and the overall fight for freedom. Despite the severe consequences if caught, enslaved individuals risked their lives to learn to read and write, and free Black communities worked tirelessly to establish schools and advocate for educational rights. The fight for access to education became a vital aspect of the broader struggle for freedom and equality, and continued even after emancipation.
The African Gally
In late October of 1705, the African Gally, a British slave ship captained by Francis Bond and Saunders, pulled out of a port in Bristol and headed for the West African coast (SlaveVoyages). While the Triangle Trade held promises of valuable metals and raw materials such as gold, ivory, redwood, and wax, what this particular voyage was interested in was slaves. Prior to this voyage Francis Bond had captained two other slave trips, the “Unity” to Barbados in 1701 and then again in 1702 (SlaveVoyages).
Map of Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade that shows common travel routes between Europe, Africa, and the Americas (“African History in Maps: Atlantic Slave Trade and Abolition,” 19th century).
The Horrors of Enslavement and the Erasure of Humanity
Sometime between October of 1705 and September of 1706 the African Gally landed in a port along the Bright of Biafra in West Africa, likely near modern day Guinea. It is here that 245 enslaved Africans were bought and boarded onto the slave ship destined for Virginia (SlaveVoyages). In the midst of the slave trade, as Hartman notes in Lose Your Mother, Africans became enslaved from war, raiding, commercialized agreements between African royals and Europeans, and the conquests of missionaries, mercenaries and privateers (Hartman 51). However, one of the most common circumstances of enslavement was captivity by another African. Africans residing in the west would capture Africans from the north, whom they believed to be barbaric and uncivilized, and make them travel hundreds of miles by foot in chains and hot weather with little to no food and water. The captives were brought to the coast where they were sold and traded to Europeans at slave markets and then transported to the Americas for plantation labor (Hartman 52). It was at these slave markets and holding dungeons that humans were stripped of their rights and reduced to property. Slaves were bound together or to walls by iron chains and rope and were packed together tightly into small spaces by the hundreds and thousands. Men were separated from women and children to reduce the threat of resistance and families were broken up. Slaves were whipped and beaten at the markets and after being sold and many were branded with a hot iron to mark who they belonged to, similarly to how cattle would be (Hartman 79). The worth of a slave was determined by many things such as their age, gender and ability. Depending on their value some slaves were held in the markets and dungeons for days and other weeks and even months. In these places food and water were scarce, and disease thickened the air. Many slaves grew ill and died before being sold or transported to their final destination. Dysentery was one of the most common diseases given that slaves were eating, sleeping and defecating in the same space. As Hartman writes, “Slavery was a state of death” (Hartman 111). The slaves’ pasts, identities and lives as they knew them were completely erased. At the slave markets and dungeons, the enslaved did not know what awaited them ahead, but they feared for their lives.
Modern day image of a site in Africa where slave markets were held during the height of the slave trade (Berry, “A Signboard Reminding People of the Former Slave Market,” 2007).
A Journey of Suffering and Loss
On September 24th of 1706, after sailing for 328 days, the African Gally disembarked at a port in Virginia near the mouth of the York River (SlaveVoyages). The African Gally’s voyage across the Atlantic was horrifying and agonizing, marked by disease, violence, and torture. Unfortunately, of the 245 slaves that embarked the African Gally in West Africa, only 196 disembarked in Virginia. On the almost year-long voyage across the Middle Passage 20% of the African Gally’s enslaved peoples died (SlaveVoyages).
Image depicting the close living quarters of enslaved people on slave ships (“Stowage of the British Slave Ship ‘Brookes,’” 1788).
Violence and Oppression in the American South
Slavery, as an institution in America, spanned from the colonial period to well past the creation of the United States. Slavery, especially in the American south, was a systematically racist and brutal institution that lasted for more than 200 years. In the southern region of America, crop was king, and the majority of enslaved people belonged to the fields, working on plantations. Slavery in the south is defined by the cruel practices and brutal conditions placed upon the enslaved. On these plantations, violence was not uncommon. White plantation owners saw extreme violence as an effective way of preventing uprisings and keeping enslaved people “in line,” using racist ideology to justify their actions. The Equal Justice Initiative states, “…enslaved people frequently suffered extreme physical violence as punishment for or warning against transgressions like running away, failing to complete assigned tasks, visiting a spouse living on another plantation, learning to read, arguing with White people, working too slowly, possessing anti-slavery materials, or trying to prevent the sale of their relatives” (Equal Justice Initiative, 20). Enslaved people in America were severely oppressed, and their experiences were defined by violence and a lack of rights.
Scars left behind by violent slave whippings that occurred on Southern plantations. During the Civil War this image was circulated in the North by abolitionists who used it as a campaign strategy for emancipation (“Scars from a Whipping on a Slave’s Back,” 1863).
The Forced Submission of the Enslaved
The governments in the south, even during the post-colonial period, prohibited and restricted the rights and autonomy of enslaved people. As noted above, violence was commonly used to restrict the abilities of enslaved people, but other means were used as well such as banning the education of enslaved people and their children. In the U.S., especially in the South, the education of enslaved people was strictly prohibited. White citizens and plantation owners feared that literate and educated slaves posed a threat to the system, enabling them to communicate and spread ideas more easily and weakening their dependence on their enslavers. Many believed that the education of enslaved peoples would lead to uprisings and extreme violence against enslavers. As a result, anti-literacy laws were passed which made it illegal for enslaved people and even freed people of color to read and write. Other laws were implemented that made it a crime to teach an enslaved person. An example of one of these anti-literacy laws is the South Carolina Act of 1740 which stated, “Whereas, the having slaves taught to write, or suffering them to be employed in writing, may be attended with great inconveniences; Be it enacted, that all and every person and persons whatsoever, who shall hereafter teach or cause any slave or slaves to be taught to write, or shall use or employ any slave as a scribe, in any manner of writing whatsoever, hereafter taught to write, every such person or persons shall, for every such offense, forfeit the sum of one hundred pounds, current money” (“Image 1 of the Negro Law of South Carolina”). By passing anti-literacy laws such as these enslavers were able to limit slaves’ capacity for independence and resistance through taking away their ability to communicate and establish organized plans and ideas. Preventing education was one medium for legally oppressing enslaved people throughout the U.S and its legacies are still felt in America even today.
The Vital Role of Education in Resistance and Freedom
Enslaved people had known freedom before they were forcibly removed from their homes and taken to North America against their will. Because of this, they not only had hope for their eventual freedom, but they were willing to fight for it. Slave resistance took on all forms, ranging from organized rebellions to small acts of defiance. One of the largest slave uprisings was the Stono Rebellion of 1739 which took place in Charleston, South Carolina. The rebellion consisted of between 60 to 100 Black people and resulted in the death of 20 White people and 40 Black rebels (Elliot and Hughes).
Newspaper article depicting enslavers’ fears of slave rebellions (“Effect of John Brown’s Invasion at the South,” 1859).
However, not all forms of slave resistance were violent. One way that many people resisted slavery was by secretly attending school to learn to read and write despite it being prohibited. While they had to be careful not to get caught as their actions were punishable by whippings, enslaved children and even adults were able to get an education through lessons in makeshift and “underground” schools. Learning how to read and write and thus communicate enabled enslaved people to spread messages and better fight for their freedom (Ealey). This important concept was recognized by both enslaved people and their enslavers which is why slaves took on such risks to get an education and enslavers punishments literacy were so extreme.
Literacy was slaves’ secret weapon. It put them on the same playing field as their enslavers and it allowed them to take back part of their humanity when so much of who they were and where they came from was stripped away. As Gibran writes, “You may chain my hands, you may shackle my feet; you may even throw me into a dark prison; but you shall not enslave my thinking, because it is free!” (Ealey). This shows the lengths slaves would go to get an education and why they felt it was worth it.
For people like Susie King and Fredrick Douglass, education and literacy played a role in an even bigger fight for freedom. Learning to read and write at a young age from his enslaver’s wife and White children in his community, Fredrick Douglass went on to use his education in becoming an abolitionist. Douglass’ literacy enabled him to write essays, speeches, and political works speaking out against slavery and advocating for abolition and emancipation in the U.S. (Ealey). Susie King who, as an enslaved child attended secret schools run by Black women in her community, was able to escape her enslaver and at 14 years old used her education to become the first teacher to openly educate African Americans. During the Civil War King also served as a nurse for the Union Army and after the war ended spent her life continuing to teach African Americans in a variety of settings (“Susie King Taylor”). While getting an education was not violent, it was a very effective and successful form of resistance during the height of slavery in the south. Knowledge really was power for enslaved individuals and revolutionized the fight for freedom, acting as a unifying force and weapon that could not be taken away.
Sources
African History in Maps: Atlantic Slave Trade and Abolition. 19th C. JSTOR, https://jstor.org/stable/community.13556993. Accessed 23 Jan. 2025.
ANONYMOUS / GREAT BRITAIN (late XVIII century), artist. Print. Stowage of the British Slave Ship “Brookes” under the Regulated Slave Trade Act of 1788. Engraving; Support: Paper, ca. 1788. WASHINGTON, D.~C, Library of Congress., JSTOR, https://jstor.org/stable/community.14786859. Accessed 23 Jan. 2025.
ANONYMOUS / UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (3rd quarter XIX century), artist. Print. Illustration for Harper’s Weekly 3, No. 151 (19 November 1859), p. 737: “Effect of John Brown’s Invasion at the South.” Wood engraving, 19 November 1859. HOUSTON (TX), Collection: Ménil Foundation Collection., JSTOR, https://jstor.org/stable/community.14776739. Accessed 23 Jan. 2025.
Atlantic Slave Trade (Legend). c.1808. JSTOR, https://jstor.org/stable/community.13560807. Accessed 23 Jan. 2025.
Ealey, Shani. “Literacy by Any Means Necessary: The History of Anti-Literacy Laws in the U.S – Oakland Literacy Coalition.” Oakland Literacy Coalition, 29 Jan. 2024, oaklandliteracycoalition.org/literacy-by-any-means-necessary-the-history-of-anti-literacy-laws-in-the-u-s/#:~:text=Anti%2Dliteracy%20laws%20made%20it,color%20to%20read%20or%20write.
Equal Justice Initiative. “SLAVERY IN AMERICA.” SLAVERY IN AMERICA: THE MONTGOMERY SLAVE TRADE, Equal Justice Initiative, 2018, pp. 8–30. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep30693.4. Accessed 10 Jan. 2025.
Elliot, Mary, and Jazmine Hughes. “A Brief History of Slavery That You Didn’t Learn in School.” The New York Times, 19 Aug. 2019, www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/08/19/magazine/history-slavery-smithsonian.html.
Hartman, Saidiya. Lose Your Mother: A Journey Along the Atlantic Slave Route. 1st ed, New York, Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2008.
Ian Berry. Ghana. Salaga. A Signboard Reminding People of the Former Slave Market. 2007. JSTOR, https://jstor.org/stable/community.18959353. Accessed 23 Jan. 2025.
“Image 1 of the Negro Law of South Carolina,.” The Library of Congress, www.loc.gov/resource/gdcmassbookdig.negrolawofsouthc00onea/?st=pdf&pdfPage=10.
Richardson, David. Bristol, Africa and the Eighteenth-Century Slave Trade to America, Vol. 1: The Years of Expansion, 1698-1729. Internet Archive, 1986, archive.org/details/bristol-record-society-38/page/n17/mode/2up.
Scars from a Whipping on a Slave’s Back. 1863. JSTOR, https://jstor.org/stable/community.13732880. Accessed 23 Jan. 2025.
Smith, Venture. A Narrative of the Life and Adventures of Venture, a Native of Africa: But Resident Above Sixty Years in the United States of America. Related by Himself. 1798. docsouth.unc.edu/neh/venture/venture.html.
“Susie King Taylor.” American Battlefield Trust, www.battlefields.org/learn/biographies/susie-taylor.
Voyage Information. www.slavevoyages.org/voyage/16016
a. Name of author: Sofia and Olivia
b. Name your topic: Legacy of Slavery in the American South as Seen Through Education
c. Why do you want to study this topic? I want to study this topic because I am from the south, and growing up here, the history of slavery was always a massive part of our education. As I got older, I realized that there are discrepancies between the ways in which slavery is taught in different parts of the country. I want to talk about this, and how education on slavery has changed over time.
d. Who’s your intended audience, and how will your blog add to what your intended
audience knows about the topic? The indented audience of our blog is anyone who wants to seek out an understanding of the legacy of slavery in the south. Open to academics and everyday people alike. If they wish to know how the legacy of slavery has evolved through education, this is a supplemental resource covering both the history of slavery in the south and it’s educational legacy.
e. Define any specialized terms a reader should know before reading the proposal.
f. What do you feel are the strengths of this draft? I feel that the draft is pretty extensive on the history and legal challenges of slavery in the southern US. I think we have done a goob job outlining the history of slavery specific to out region, and built the foundation for which we can elaborate on the legacy of it in later blog posts.
g. List any thing you’re still working on and would like feedback on. (These questions
should not generally have “yes/no” answers, as in, “Is the paper well organized?” but
should ideally be worded in a way that invites discussion, e.g. “Show me one or two
places that could be better organized.”) Let us know if theres any sections that would be reworked/reordered to flow better, or if there are instances in which we could elaborate more on a certain topic.
a. Name of author: Sofia Cieplinski
b. Name your topic: Legacies of Slavery in the South in Education
c. Why do you want to study this topic? It’s interesting to me that how different areas in were involved in the slave trade affects how people learn and are educated about slavery in those regions. We picked the south because we had the most background knowledge on slavery in this area.
d. Who’s your intended audience, and how will your blog add to what your intended
audience knows about the topic? I would say our audience is the general American pubic with an added appeal to those in southern states. The goal of this blog is to inform readers about the history of slavery in the south and how its legacies have impacted the way it is taught there. While the general population likely has knowledge about the historical aspects of slavery in the south, many people are not educated on how slavery still affects life today. Are aim is to introduce these impacts and give insight on how or why they came to be.
e. Define any specialized terms a reader should know before reading the proposal. There are no terms that need extra definition.
f. What do you feel are the strengths of this draft? Some strengths of this draft are that is well structure and interesting by tying together narrative style writing with fact based elements that use historical evidence. I feel that this draft answers all the key guiding questions and uses sufficient evidence to back up its claims.
g. List any thing you’re still working on and would like feedback on. (These questions
should not generally have “yes/no” answers, as in, “Is the paper well organized?” but
should ideally be worded in a way that invites discussion, e.g. “Show me one or two
places that could be better organized.”) What are some areas that I can use more evidence to support my claims and aid my argument?
Criteria
1. Argument: Does the blog tell one, cohesive story about slavery and emancipation in a given country/region? Does each blog post have a central thesis that builds to an overarching argument?
Exceptional
2. Organization: Does each blog post advance its argument through a well-organized, logical interpretation? Does each post advance a larger argument throughout the entire blog across all 3 entries?
Effective
3. Conventions and Mechanics: Is the blog’s writing clear and concise? Does each blog post cite its sources? Do the posts reflect an effort to edit for errors and proofread for effective sentence construction and word choice?
Effective
4. Evidence: Does each post cite at least 5 sources (2 primary; 3 secondary) as supporting evidence to develop and enhance its story through relevant details or quotes? Is 1 primary and 1 secondary source independently researched? Are the secondary sources scholarly, and are the primary sources relevant to the timeline topic?
Effective
5. Evidence Analysis: Does each blog post analyze the evidence to support its argument rather than present it as general summary or opinion? Do they consider multiple interpretations, the origins, and author of the source?
Partially effective
6. Visuals: Does the blog’s captions, the identified events/people/subjects, and other visual content convey the overarching argument of the project? Do the captions describe the appropriate sources/visual content concisely?
Ineffective
7. Historical Thinking: Does the blog place evidence in its historical context and address the ideas and actions of key historical actors, subjects, and authors? Does the blog consider the global histories and legacies of slavery? Does it communicate why its events are significant and how they relate to each other?
Effective
Positive round. Note something very specific that you really liked. It can be something about content, organization, voice, or style. It could be a particular paragraph or section that you thought worked especially well. It’s OK if someone else has already made your positive comment; be sure to say it again because it’s good reinforcement. Do not leave this blank! Write something here!
I really liked the way Olivia constructed the narrative- focusing on a specific ship and following an enslaved person from their life before slavery, capture, their voyage on the ship, and subsequent life in the US
Summarize the author’s argument/purpose (do not copy from the text; paragraphs in your own words).
Give an overview of how enslaved people lived in all status enslaved, freedmen, and pre-slavery.
Writer’s questions. Use the questions on the draft and jot down your answer to each question the writer asked in their wrapper comment.
How the blog was organized makes it very easy to read. There is not much I would change with organization, except, if possible, make the sections all the same size.
What else? Other comments, questions, suggestions. As always, keep a positive tone and make sure you deliver even critical comments in the spirit of helpful feedback.
At certain points (1 or 2), more analysis of evidence is needed. More information about the celebration junkanoo or other cultural events could be beneficial in future rounds
Motivational round. Remember that what is said last tends to stick in the writer’s mind. The single biggest purpose we serve as a writing group is to motivate people to want to write more! Write one thing here that you can say honestly to this writer to give him or her a big sendoff from the group and make him or her want to get right back to work on this project.
Great job! Very good organization that makes the blog easy to read.
1. Positive round:
– I very much like the overall organization, use of evidence, and story telling throughout the entire blog. I thought you provided enough information for the blog to be effective in conveying the main point of your argument.
2. Summarize writer’s argument:
– The argument is about how the Virginia colony played a significant role in establishing slavery in North America and how education plays a role in this.
3. Writer’s Question:
– In the last paragraph, you talked about the festival, Junkanoo. This specific section is about the enslaved peoples acts of resistance, so I think it would be beneficial if you wrote a sentence or two about how and why exactly this festival should be considered as a form of resistance.
4. One other aspect I think you could improve on is the lack of images. I think it would help if you put images throughout the blog rather than just at the end.
5. Overall, I think the blog was very well done. The different sections were organized well, it was easy to follow, and you used evidence effectively throughout the blog.
Rubric:
1. Exceptional
2. Exceptional
3. Exceptional
4. Exceptional
5. Exceptional
6. Visuals
7. Effective
Date: Jan 23
Version: 2
This revision addressed visual and substantive feedback. In revising this blog I added relevant images to help aid the overall argument and engage the reader. I also revised the post for clarity, precision, and grammar. While I took out some sections that provided background historical information about slavery I added in elements about education and how education played a role in slave resistance and the fight for freedom. My goal with this revision was to make the overall argument of the blog stronger and more present throughout and to introduce claims earlier on in order to set up the later blogs about the legacies of slavery on education today for success.